56 The fresh new immigration institution declined Kristin Rupperts application to have permanent citizen condition and you can she try bought out from the country even with their particular long-label relationship with a good Canadian national, Elizabeth.B. Brownlie. Find Colin Leslie, No Unnecessary Hardship, Page States Xtra! (nine December 1994 ) 13 [Leslie, Undue Adversity]. However their attorneys were able to overturn the newest refusal when she ran above the case officers head (Craig, supra note 46).

In another case, Marco Tarelho, a great Brazilian national, was also refused despite his four-year experience of Blair Boyle, a great Canadian man

58 For the January 1999, the newest minister put-out a departmental white report to your immigration and you can refugee solutions. The brand new report requisite fair treatment of common-laws and you will exact same-sex people from the immigration legislation and you may laws: Declining permanent quarters cannot merely deny a benefit to brand new … same-sex partner, but may efficiently reject Canadians the right to live with the lifestyle lovers …

the same time as the a courtroom problem was launched against the national trying to changes to fifty-seven government statutes, including the immigration laws, you to definitely discriminated facing gay dudes and you may lesbians.59